DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! Free Traffic Tips is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

Jump to original thread »
Author

Is Andy Beard Getting a Raw Deal? | (Kinda Rant-y but Has a Point)

Started by Tinu · 5 months ago

Because of the number of posts being made to question Google’s reasoning behind and/or application of their policies, I just want to clear a few things up before I start in on my diatribe on this issue.
Number one, I’m not Google bashing. I hate it when people just co ... Continue reading »

11 comments

  • 100% agreed. As long as a link is relevant to the topic (or in Andy's case even an editorial link), it shouldn't matter wether it's paid or not.

    I'm not gonna quote my whole post on this, just this much:

    If it is possible to base the price of an AdWords ad on a quality score, then Google should be able to judge links by something that really counts - relevance.
  • Hey send me the link to your post and I'll add a link to it in the post body. I want to link to everyone who is specifically talking about this incident and ones like it.
  • Oh, and welcome to the site. :)
  • Hey Tinu, the link is http://bloggersjourney.com/why-google-shouldnt-....

    And thanks for the welcome :-)
  • Done. And you're welcome. ... and I don't get your logo. It says "create your own blog" which gives me the impression that it's a tool, rather than a blog... what's up with that? :)

    Nuts. I meant to set you a trackback link and now I have to go out...
  • The blog's there to help people who want to create their own blog.

    Okay, and I wanted a memorable, dynamic tagline. :-)
  • But that's kind of my point though, the tagline is memorable but confusing. I'd do a poll if I were you, or add something that specifies tips. Just my two cents... I spend a good ten minutes looking for the "create blog" button.
  • Hmm, good idea. I wanted to install a poll plugin anyway. Would be a nice first run.

    Thanks for the hint. I'll try to come up with some alternatives now. :-)
  • No problem. Glad it didn't come across as nosy or nitpicky.
  • Oh, no. Constructive criticism is always welcome. :-)
  • When you go to many webmaster forums. it is obvious that many people can't see past the Google page rank. They seem obsessed with scoring higher even at the expense of the visitors of their site. For this Google often chastises those webmasters, you see many posts of that sort in Matt Cutts blog.

    It's interesting that Google likewise can't see past it's own ranking system. They feel that everything you do must have something to do with Page Rank. A good example are reviews. It's not difficult to see the difference between blogs that offer an objective review and others that are just doing it to pass PR. Google seems to forget that the whole reason for having a blog is to share your opinion, that opinion can include other sites.

    Newspapers, magazines and a host of other formats all have both paid views and paid advertisements. Google appears to feel that, on the internet, they are the only ones that can get paid to advertise. And if you are horning in on their market, like a schoolyard bully, they plan on making life rough for you.

Add New Comment

Returning? Login